Skip to content Skip to main navigation Skip to footer

County to continue using vendor for Benton Area Transit services

The Board of Commissioners, County Counsel and County Administrator on the dias

In a Nov. 16 meeting, the Benton County Board of Commissioners voted unanimously to continue working with a contracted vendor to provide Benton Area Transit services. The new contract period will begin Jan. 1, 2028.

Last December, the Board directed staff to develop a plan for internal delivery of transit services. A project team spent 10 months working on the self-performance model.

At the same time, the team explored what would need to be added to the current contract to ensure detailed reporting and accountability in the future. Both are needed to meet changing requirements for the federal funding that supports BAT services.

Once both plans were developed, it was up to the Board of Commissioners to choose which option staff should pursue in developing the 2027-29 biennial budget, and which would be saved as Plan B. The backup option would be ready to quickly implement if needed to ensure continuity of services.

In a Nov. 10 work session (timecode 12:30) during the Board of Commissioners Goal Setting meeting, the BAT project team presented updated cost estimates to the Board along with the strengths and limitations of each plan.

The presentation included a staff recommendation: to continue operating the service with a vendor, under contract terms written to ensure increased accountability and rigor by both the vendor and the County.

What changed?

In December 2025, the Board of Commissioners was presented with a recommendation to develop a self-performance plan for Benton Area Transit. A program analysis conducted by transportation consultant Kittelson & Associates pointed to self-performance as a better way to address concerns about reporting compliance, adapt to frequently changing federal and state requirements and increase opportunities to provide expanded services.

Less than a year later, the staff’s recommendation was to not begin implementing the self-performance plan they had just developed. Instead, they encouraged the Board to continue using contracted service providers, but with new clauses in the contract and more oversight.

The second recommendation does not contradict the first.

“Remember, in 2025 the Board didn’t vote to implement a self-performance model—they directed us to develop a plan for one,” said Public Works Director Gary Stockhoff. “For years, the County has operated BAT without a contingency plan. If there was an emergency or unexpected event, we had no backup plan.”

County Administrator Rick Crager reinforced the importance of being prepared for uncertainty.

“Responsible governance requires us to be able to assure continuity of operations. Having a Plan B reduces risk for everyone involved. Community members won’t suddenly lose services because we’re unprepared. The County won’t suddenly lose funding.  It’s a great outcome from this whole process.”

Nick Metzger from Kittleson & Associates explained to the Board on Nov. 10 that funding was a factor in the new recommendation. When the first recommendation was made in Dec. 2025, State Transportation Improvement Funding—the money that pays for BAT services—was expected to double no later than the next legislative session. That didn’t end up happening.

Without the expected funding increase, the best way to maximize the dollars the County does have is through a competitive procurement process. When the County issues a Request for Proposals, potential vendors can compete for a contract to provide the most effective service possible with the funds available.  

Adding a dedicated transit coordinator to the County’s workforce was another change that tipped the scales in favor of continuing to contract out. Maya O’Neal joined the Benton Area Transit team in March 2026. Within two months, her positive impact on contract management, data collection and reporting was clear.

“Having a Benton County staff person here to administer BAT, instead of relying on an agreement with staff employed by another agency, has made a huge difference,” said Crager. “That alone was a significant improvement because it positions us to have the accountability and oversight we need. We’re in a better place to effectively manage our contracts.”

The County hopes to increase staffing to administer Benton Area Transit. A position for a second full-time employee to work with O’Neal has been put forth for consideration for the 2027-29 budget.

Next steps

Building the 2027-29 budget, with a contract for BAT services included, is the next step. This work will continue for several months. The recommended budget will be considered, modified and approved by the Budget Committee in April and May in a series of public hearings.

The final budget will be considered and adopted by the Board of Commissioners in June. It will then take effect on July 1, 2027.

Because the procurement process takes several months, the Request for Proposals for the new Benton Area Transit contract will be released early in 2027, before the budget is adopted, with an intended service start date of January 1, 2028. Vendor selection is expected to happen in summer 2027, with the contract negotiated in the fall.

Visit the Benton Area Transit Service Delivery project for more information.

Back to top